“An article in last week’s issue, ‘Kashrut War Has Holy Overtones,’ inadvertently crossed the line from news reporting to sarcasm in the eyes of a number of readers whose views we respect. The piece dealt, in part, with a pizza and wine bar in Brooklyn hiring an interim kashrut certifier named Menachem Mendel Schneerson, the namesake of the Lubavitcher Rebbe. It prompted numerous comments on Facebook, including puns, memes and other attempts at humor we cited that were seen as disrespectful to the Rebbe. No disrespect was intended, but we apologize for our lack of sensitivity.”
Rabbi Ari Shishler
@Rabbishish Replying to @Mottel @NYJewishWeekSad to see how a Jewish mouthpiece lose sense of what a Tzadik is. Need to refresh some old school values. See laws of Talmud Torah.
Leibel@Squilled Replying to @BersEchoChamber @NYJewishWeekAn apology shoulders responsibility and takes corrective measures. This one obnoxiously blames those who took offense. Better left unsaid
July 6, 2017, 9:45 am
It’s a kashrut shootout at the OK Corral.
And it involves Basil Pizza & Wine Bar, an upscale kosher Italian eatery just north of Eastern Parkway in Crown Heights, which recently dueled in a pizza war with Calabria, the recently opened Roman-style kosher pizza eatery across the street. (The two battled it out in religious court in March over competition for business and customers.)
This time around, though, Basil is trading volleys with its former kashrut certification provider, the OK.
On June 26, the popular New York-based kashrut agency posted a “Kashrus Alert” on its Facebook page to inform customers that it removed its certification from Basil.
“Basil NY violated the Kashrus Standards of their contract with OK Kosher,” the organization posted on their Facebook page. “They were not willing to maintain the standards that are required under the Certification Contract. Therefore we had no choice but to remove our certification.”
The clause they allegedly violated: working on Shabbat. A representative from the OK, who requested to remain anonymous, said the organization removed its certification because Basil was caught doing work on Shabbat.
Responding immediately to the news, Basil fired back on its Facebook page that the whole hullabaloo was a “big misunderstanding.” Some routine “maintenance work” outside the Basil building was misconstrued as work on Shabbat, the statement said.
“To reiterate, none of our Kashrus standards have been compromised in the slightest.”
A Basil spokesperson could not be reached for comment.
A source close to the matter told The Jewish Week that the OK’s move is already having a negative effect on business. Removing a trusted certification immediately throws the reliability and trustworthiness of the operation into question, the source said. The restaurant “has already suffered.”
A visit to the restaurant last Thursday afternoon found only three tables filled.
The new interim kashrut certifier is (yes, really!) Menachem Mendel Schneerson, the son of a prominent rabbi in the neighborhood and a namesake of the late Lubavitcher Rebbe, Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson, who led the Chabad-Lubavitch movement.
The news — and the name of the new interim certifier — lit up the Crown Heights Jewish Facebook world.
“Basil is moving to the Ohel?” joked one commenter, referring to the gravesite in Queens where the late Rabbi Schneerson is buried.
Another created a meme with the text, “So Kosher the Rebbe Himself Wants a Taste…”
Recalling the Calabria faceoff, one commenter wrote “and now Calabria is under the hashgocha (certification) of the Baal Shem Tov,” an 18th-century Jewish mystic credited with founding chasidic Judaism. Comments went on to say that other local kosher eateries would be under the certification of famous rabbis of generations past.
What none of the meme-sters seemed to realize is that even Basil’s name carries with it some plant yichus, so to speak. Basil is referred to as “the king of herbs” or the “royal/kingly plant,” based on its Greek derivation, apropos of the Rebbe as King Moshiach. And a popular Asian variety of the herb is called “holy basil,” befitting this new holy war over kashrut.
Schneerson could not be reached for comment.
There’s no getting around it, if you’re familiar with Chabad Messianism, “Melech HaMashgiach” is funny.
Mashgiach, mashgiach, mashgiach … aye, aye, aye, aye, yay, yay, yay.
“Yechi Adoneinu Moreinu v’Rabbeinu Melech haMashgiach l’olam vo’ed!“
“Long Live our Master, our Teacher, and our Rabbi, King Kosher Supervisor, for ever.”
Even if such quips are disrespectful, they pale in comparison to Chabad’s own malfeasance — frequently reported in the media — which is a far greater disgrace of their Rebbe. But few, if any, in Chabad complain that Shalom Rubashkin, Mendel Tevel, Nisson Friedman, or Boruch Shlomo Cunin is a disgrace to the Rebbe and embarrassment to the movement. On the contrary, Chabad defends them, takes collections of funds on their behalf, and attempts to justify or cover-up the worst Chabad has to offer. It’s difficult to admire a rebbe who represents the distribution of dishonest, nepotistic, schnorring, and often criminal rabbis from Crown Heights.
I once held a lot of respect for the mythological version of their rebbe that Chabad teaches. After some independent research on the Rebbe, and observing the behaviors of local Chabad rabbis (and many worldwide), I realize that respect was unjustified and misplaced.
My brother, with the upcoming Yomim Noraim, I want to wish you and your family a Kesiva V’Chasima Tovah. You should all have a sweet New Year full of only Berachos, Torah Mitzvos, and Avodah. Also, you should all have a very Simchadikke Sukkos.
I also hereby forgive anything you might have said that hurt me in any way (not that you ever really said anything insulting). But I also want to apologize for any time I might have said something to upset or hurt YOU. Please forgive me.
Kol Tuv!
LikeLike
Aish,
I’m going to repeat what I said in the previous thread:
“You are just the most polite fellow on Earth. You don’t owe me an apology for anything, nor to ask any forgiveness. I don’t know why you get such a hard time at DIN. You’re really a nice guy.”
You remind me of the BT I used to be. I used to think this formality was important before Rosh Hashana and Yom Kippur. I don’t anymore. I think it’s a silly year-end ritual. Instead I apologize to people I care about that I may have hurt in a more timely manner year-round. And for those who have hurt me or my family, if the offense is big, I simply don’t forgive nor regret any reciprocal hurt I dished out. But those are big offenses, not like some blog comments that may or may not really represent who that person is. I don’t think (even heated) Internet exchanges are a really big deal.
I’m sure this blog and some of my comments are very offensive to some people. But I’m not a warm-fuzzy, write to make people feel good blogger. My content and opinions are bound to offend; even some people I like who differ in opinion will be offended sometimes. Or something I haven’t expressed correctly may be considered offensive. It happens, and life goes on.
If I haven’t offended you yet, perhaps I should apologize preemptively. :) Anyway, we’re all good here. And you really are a mensch. You should really have all of the great blessings that HaShem has to offer you. I hope your yom tovim will be beautiful, meaningful, and joyous.
BTW, it’s Jews like you, and some of the truly wonderful examples of integrity and caring people in frumkeit, that keep me hanging on to my observance of Jewish life. Without these, I’d have dropped it cold long ago.
LikeLike
Please!
LikeLike
LOL. You please… stop it already.
I’ll apologize if my delay to respond was read as ignoring you.
I just don’t give this blog a lot of attention now for a few reasons:
First, it’s time consuming. And I realize that devoting a lot of time to frum malfeasance takes time away from being with those I love, namely my wife and young children. If I let too much of that time slip away focusing on Chabad and other criminals, then they have effectively ripped me off again. Of the time and money I’ve lost to religious foolishness, the money can be replaced… the time is forever lost. I’m very careful with both now.
Second, I love my Jewish culture. And focusing so much on it’s flaws is really a bummer. It becomes difficult to find beauty in Judaism when I focus on all of the false piety, cultism, dishonesty, stupidity, and horrifying stories from the frum world that really appear never-ending.
And third, FrumWatch is a very effective and well done replacement for the old Failedmessiah blog. DIN, which has been around for a long time, is a great blog too. Except perhaps as a watchdog site and warning sign regarding problems in Chabad (my primary concern), this site really doesn’t need to fill that niche. The end of FM blog resulted in three or four others being created, so my defiant reaction to the ultra-Orthodox buyout and cover-up is not really needed. Fact is, I enjoy reading and commenting on blogs more than I enjoy publishing one.
Now it’s time to gear-up for Shabbat, and I wish you and your loved ones a great one. Kol tov.
LikeLike
Thank you, Chafraud (I wish I could call you by a better name than… THAT, but I don’t know your real one, so…). I am, by the way, not a BT, but, I wish I did Teshuva more…. :) Also, yes, I do apologize year-round for offenses I have committed (afterall, Teshuva is not just for the Yomim Noraim). But as we are taught that we do not get forgiven for Bein Adam LaChaveiro aveiros until we earn forgiveness from the person we hurt, I believe it important to do so.
Your comment was actually extremely touching — and you say you’re not a warm-fuzzy blogger… :)
IY”H, perhaps we could keep in touch…
Kesiva V’Chasima Tovah and a Gut Shabbos!
LikeLike
“(I wish I could call you by a better name than… THAT, but I don’t know your real one, so…)”
Sometimes I wish I’d picked something nicer that represents me and not what I oppose. Perhaps it will change in the future and I’ll drop the anonymity (when it’s less of a risk to my family).
Till then, you can call me anything you like. Most people do… LOL.
And feel welcome to keep in touch. It’s always a pleasure to have these exchanges.
btw, I’m not a BT either. I just bought in to that stupid label for a decade or two.
LikeLike
Well, although the username I use it nice, I feel safe enough to tell you that my real name if Refoel.
LikeLike
YOU ARE DISGUSTING!!!
LikeLike
Hi Rev,
I was thinking of you today. You must be having great fun now that Trump the chump is Pres. Right up your street perhaps ,although not in your neck of the woods in California . Maybe I’m wrong about you being a fan of his, because he’s Netanyahu’s best mate. 😁 The last 18 months have been very eventful. I had more surgery and after a recent nerve root block I am now pain free & don’t require morphine. Six months ago I moved back to the North Shore to a lovely new house , very close to Auckland’s best beach and native bush both of which I love. I wasn’t able to use a computer whilst flat on my back and my old smart phone wasn’t up to the job for e mail & news groups, although I could read websites & Jewish blogs. I contributed to ‘ Failed Messiah ‘ on a regular basis, but the site is now defunct (unfortunately) since Chabad purchased it. Recently I purchased a new state of the art smartphone & a new laptop & I intend being more out there online, especially in winter. What have you been up to? Have you moved to Oregon or are you still in Cali? It seems to me the US is a f…..g madhouse at the moment ,the mass shootings If I want a good laugh I read the Daily Fail (American & British sites) which attract feedback from every Trump fan, gun nut and Brexit supporter on the planet. I am so glad I am far away from all the mayhem in the world , especially if Trump & Kim Jong Un start going nuclear. Next year I want to go to Europe & Israel , depending of course on how my neck is & the state of the world. I look forward to hearing from you soon and I will keep in touch more regularly now. Regards Tilly
LikeLike
Hi Shayna G!
How cool to see a familiar name from the old FM days.
I honestly don’t give a lot of thought to the political climate of the US or Israel. It never feels good to read about it and there’s nothing I can do to change it, so my strategy is mostly just to survive it. If I have anything positive to say about President Trump it’s that he saved us from Hillary. People in power care about power, not people… whether in politics or religion, it’s all the same BS.
It’s great to hear you’re doing well, on the mend, and don’t require pain killers. They can be so dangerous. And congratulations on your new home and tech devices. Please visit or email sometimes, even if I’m not publishing much these days.
I don’t know if it was ever confirmed that Chabad was behind the buyout of Failed Messiah, but it’s enough to know that it was a cover-up by Orthodox Jews who simply wanted to hide the truth. So much for God, Torah and truth, eh?
I’ve had no plans to move from California. And since I am backing away from the scam of organized religion and its associated expenses I find our family is recovering financially. Between Chabad parasites always crying that they needed more (they have more in common with fleas than dogs :) ), and the cost of Orthodox schools, our family was sucked for all it was worth. “Charity” is a concept of my past now. I only give where I can identify real integrity and the feeling of saying “no” to a solicitor (like Chabad) is really a good one. One child is almost finished with yeshiva, and our remaining children will likely finish in secular school since they already have their initial Jewish education. I hope to steer them all away from becoming frum ultra-Orthodox (extreme Judaism). If they can’t take Judaism on their own terms, then they may as well not be Jewish at all – a lesson our whole family has learned. Backing off of religion translates into financial comfort, peace of mind, and a better relationship with God for us. We’re in a happier, recovering, situation now and just taking care of ourselves. When I find I have some more free time I will do some more blogging.
I still think it’s important to warn people about the ways Chabad-Lubavitch dupes people out of their money while pretending to be loving and righteous. They are very good at projecting images that cover up their selfishness, malfeasance and sickness. And other ultra-Orthodox groups can be pretty horrible too (see Satmar, Gur). Perhaps we shouldn’t be so down on the current state of secular politics since religion’s end-game is a backward, primitive theocracy.
LikeLike